Why Legal Separation Might Not Be the Best Choice in California

Did you know that the divorce rate in the U.S. is currently 12.4 per 1,000 people, with at least one divorce for 18% of Asian American women and 16% of men? The American Psychological Association (APA) estimates that the probability of a first marriage ending in divorce is 41% in 2024. 

In California, there are only two grounds for filing for divorce. Couples must prove irreconcilable differences or incurable insanity. Legal separation may seem a good choice for couples who want to live apart without divorcing, but California has better options.

Orange County family law attorney Lisa R. McCall says that people who are legally separated can do everything they can do in a divorce, like dividing their joint property and making decisions about child custody, spousal support, and child support.

Let’s learn why legal separation may not be the ideal path forward in California.

Financial Implications of Legal Separation

The financial impacts of civil separation can provide insight into how California divides assets and debts. You must consider the financial implications when you and your spouse legally split. The goal of California courts is to achieve a fair and equitable distribution of assets and obligations.

The court will evaluate each spouse’s income, earning capacity, and financial demands during legal separation. The court decides spousal maintenance (alimony) based on this evaluation. One spouse may have to financially support the other during separation.

Legal separation can impact taxes, insurance, and retirement benefits. Consult with a financial advisor or attorney to understand the implications of legal separation for your financial situation.

Impact on Property Rights

Assets acquired during the marriage are considered community property in California and are divided equally upon divorce. In a legal separation, the court can distribute property and debts between couples, affecting their rights and finances. Even after a legal separation, property and debts acquired after the separation date may be common property. This could complicate the allocation of post-divorce assets and debts.

Factors such as prenuptial agreements, the nature of the assets, and each spouse’s contributions to the property may influence how the court divides the property. Seeking legal advice to handle these property rights can help protect your interests during a legal separation in California.

Alimony and Spousal Support Considerations

Alimony is a financial support payment made by one spouse to the other. To help both spouses maintain a similar lifestyle after divorce, California courts may grant alimony. The length of the marriage, each spouse’s earning capacity, and household contributions affect the amount and duration.

When considering divorce, examine how alimony will influence your finances. Depending on your situation, you may receive or pay alimony. The higher-earning spouse may have to help their ex-partner financially. Alimony may help the lower-earning spouse adjust to singlehood.

Complications in Divorce Proceedings

Divorce issues, notably alimony and spousal support, must be understood to navigate the legal procedure. Disagreements about asset partition, child custody, and financial support complicate divorce. These disputes often result in lengthy court fights and higher legal bills. Divorce can be emotional, making it hard to reach decisions.

Financial, asset, and child custody claims require significant documentation, which complicates divorce proceedings. Inaccurate and incomplete documentation can delay and dispute divorce. Handling the complex legal system without legal representation might lead to bad results. Know the probable challenges of divorce.

Legal separation vs. divorce in California

Legal separation involves court orders that dictate the rights and responsibilities of each spouse while they are still legally married. In this arrangement, assets and debts may be divided, support issues addressed, and child custody determined, but the marriage remains intact.

Divorce terminates the marital relationship entirely, allowing both parties to remarry and severing financial ties. Unlike legal separation, divorce finalizes the division of assets and debts. and may impact benefits like Social Security or health insurance.

Legal separation may be chosen for religious or personal reasons but divorce is often preferred for a clean break and the opportunity to start over. Consider the consequences of each option carefully and seek legal advice to make an informed decision based on your unique circumstances.

Conclusion

While legal separation in California allows couples to live apart and address issues like property division, child custody, and spousal support without ending their marriage, it may not always be the best choice. The financial implications, impact on property rights, and potential complications of divorce proceedings can make legal separation a complex and less favorable option. Divorce, on the other hand, provides a clean break, allowing both parties to remarry and fully sever financial ties. It’s essential to consider the unique circumstances of your situation and seek legal advice to make an informed decision that best suits your needs.

For more info visit Kaz Magazine